Acosta Press Conference Defending the Epstein NPA
Secretary of Labor Alexander Acosta holds a press conference attempting to defend his 2008 handling of the Epstein non-prosecution agreement, arguing the deal was the best available outcome given the circumstances. The performance is widely seen as unsuccessful.
People Involved
Event Details
On July 10, 2019, four days after Epstein’s federal arrest and amid intense bipartisan calls for his resignation, Secretary of Labor Alexander Acosta held an unusual press conference to defend his handling of the 2008 Epstein non-prosecution agreement.
Acosta argued that his office had secured the best available outcome in circumstances where he believed a full federal prosecution might have failed, that the NPA had at least resulted in Epstein serving jail time, and that the SDNY’s 2019 case was possible only because his office had not charged the same conduct.
He defended the decision to keep the NPA secret from victims by arguing for prosecutorial discretion norms. He denied that Epstein’s social connections had influenced the deal’s terms.
Critics and victim advocates found the press conference inadequate. The argument that a better-than-nothing deal justified its terms, and particularly its secrecy from victims, failed to satisfy those who had watched the NPA operate for a decade to protect Epstein from accountability.
Two days later, on July 12, Acosta resigned as Labor Secretary.
His press conference was later characterized by journalists and legal scholars as a case study in how powerful institutions attempt to justify accountability failures without acknowledging their magnitude.